CSS 2018CriminologyQ. 7
To what extent Interpol has been successful in reducing organized crime at international level. Discuss
#cssnexusBy CSS Nexus Team ·
This answer to the CSS 2018 Criminology paper (Q. 7) was written by the CSS Nexus team. Read the outline first, then see how each point is developed.
Outline
- 1. Introduction
- 2. Overview: INTERPOL's origin, structure and tools
- 3. Successes of INTERPOL against organised crime
- ✓Notices and fugitive tracking; I-24/7 and databases; coordinated operations; drug trafficking; human trafficking; financial and cybercrime; capacity building; neutral platform
- 4. Limitations of INTERPOL
- ✓No arrest powers; dependence on members; political misuse of notices; resource limits; uneven capacity; lack of data quality; competing bodies; scale of organised crime
- 5. Overall assessment and Pakistan's experience
- 6. Conclusion
Answer
Introduction
In his foreword to the UN Convention against Transnational Organized Crime, Kofi Annan wrote: "If crime crosses all borders, so must law enforcement." Organised crime, from drug cartels to human traffickers and cyber gangs, operates across borders, while national police stop at their frontiers. INTERPOL exists to bridge that gap. It has achieved important successes, but it is not an international police force, and its effect on organised crime is real yet limited.
Overview
The idea of international police cooperation was first discussed at the International Criminal Police Congress in Monaco in 1914. The International Criminal Police Commission was founded in Vienna in 1923 and renamed INTERPOL in 1956. Headquartered in Lyon, France, it has 196 member countries, each with a National Central Bureau (NCB); Pakistan's NCB in Islamabad is run by the FIA. Article 3 of its Constitution forbids any intervention in matters of a political, military, religious or racial character. Its main tools are the colour-coded Notices (red for wanted persons, yellow for missing persons, and others), the secure I-24/7 communications network and about 19 databases.
INTERPOL's growth
- Monaco Congress (1914)
- ICPC in Vienna (1923)
- Renamed INTERPOL (1956)
- Headquarters in Lyon (1989)
- 196 member countries
Successes of INTERPOL against organised crime
1. Notices and tracking of fugitives.
Red Notices alert police worldwide to wanted persons and have led to thousands of arrests of fugitives, including drug lords and traffickers who fled abroad. (Reference: INTERPOL, Annual Report 2022; INTERPOL, Notices factsheet.)
2. I-24/7 and global databases.
The I-24/7 network, launched in 2002, connects all NCBs and gives access to databases on wanted persons, stolen and lost travel documents, stolen vehicles, fingerprints and DNA. Border checks against the Stolen and Lost Travel Documents database detect criminals travelling on false passports. (Reference: INTERPOL, Databases factsheet.)
3. Coordinated global operations.
INTERPOL organises multinational operations in which many countries act at once. Operation Pangea, running since 2008, targets illegal online sale of medicines and has seized millions of fake pills. (Reference: INTERPOL, Operation Pangea press releases.)
4. Drug trafficking.
Operations such as Lionfish against drug smuggling in Latin America, Africa and Asia have resulted in large seizures of cocaine, methamphetamine and arrests of couriers and networks. (Reference: INTERPOL, Operation Lionfish press releases.)
5. Human trafficking and migrant smuggling.
In Operation Liberterra (2023), police in 54 countries arrested about 2,500 suspects and identified thousands of possible victims. (Reference: INTERPOL press release, Operation Liberterra, 2023.)
6. Financial and cybercrime.
Operations such as HAECHI against online financial fraud have frozen bank accounts and recovered millions of dollars, and the Global Rapid Intervention of Payments (I-GRIP) mechanism helps stop fraudulent transfers. (Reference: INTERPOL, Operation HAECHI press releases, 2021-2024.)
7. Capacity building and training.
INTERPOL trains police in developing countries in forensics, cybercrime investigation and border management, raising the global standard of policing. (Reference: INTERPOL, Capacity Building and Training Directorate.)
8. A neutral platform for cooperation.
Because of its political neutrality, countries with poor relations can still share criminal information through INTERPOL channels. (Reference: INTERPOL Constitution, arts. 2-3; Mathieu Deflem, Policing World Society, Oxford University Press, 2002.)
INTERPOL's successes
- 01Notices
- 02I-24/7 and databases
- 03Global operations
- 04Drug trafficking
- 05Human trafficking
- 06Financial crime
- 07Capacity building
- 08Neutral platform
Limitations of INTERPOL
1. No arrest powers.
INTERPOL has no agents who can arrest anyone; a Red Notice is only a request, and arrest depends on national law. (Reference: INTERPOL, What is a Red Notice?)
2. Dependence on member countries.
Its effectiveness depends on members sharing data and acting on alerts; many NCBs do not regularly enter data or check databases at borders. (Reference: Deflem, Policing World Society, 2002.)
3. Political misuse of notices.
Some governments have tried to use Red Notices against dissidents and opponents, damaging INTERPOL's credibility and leading to reforms of its review process. (Reference: Fair Trials International, Strengthening Respect for Human Rights, Strengthening INTERPOL, 2013.)
4. Limited resources.
Its annual budget is small, under about €200 million, compared with the vast profits of organised crime. (Reference: INTERPOL, Annual Report; UNODC, Estimating Illicit Financial Flows, 2011.)
5. Uneven national capacity.
Developing countries often lack the technology, training and integrity needed to use INTERPOL's tools effectively. (Reference: INTERPOL, Capacity Building Directorate.)
6. Data quality and speed.
Incomplete or outdated information in databases reduces effectiveness, and slow national responses let criminals escape. (Reference: INTERPOL, Rules on the Processing of Data, 2011.)
7. Overlap with other bodies.
Regional agencies such as EUROPOL, ASEANAPOL and AFRIPOL, and bilateral channels, sometimes replace INTERPOL for serious cases. (Reference: Europol Regulation (EU) 2016/794.)
8. The sheer scale of organised crime.
UNODC estimates that transnational organised crime generates hundreds of billions of dollars a year; no single agency can reduce it substantially without political will and economic action. (Reference: UNODC, Transnational Organized Crime: The Globalized Illegal Economy, 2012.)
Limits of INTERPOL
- No arrest powers
- Dependence on members
- Political misuse
- Small budget
- Uneven capacity
- Data quality
- Overlapping bodies
- Scale of crime
Overall assessment and Pakistan's experience
INTERPOL has been successful as a facilitator: it makes cooperation faster, catches fugitives and disrupts networks through joint operations. It has not, however, reduced organised crime overall, which has grown with globalisation and the internet. Its success depends on how well national police use it. Pakistan's FIA has used Red Notices to seek fugitives abroad and to receive wanted persons, but extradition often fails because of weak documentation, political cases and the absence of treaties with many countries.
Conclusion
As Kofi Annan put it, if crime crosses all borders, so must law enforcement. INTERPOL narrows that gap through notices, databases, operations and training, and it has scored notable successes against drugs, trafficking and financial crime. Yet without arrest powers, adequate funds and full cooperation from members, it can only support, not replace, national action. Its success is therefore partial: significant in coordination, limited in actually reducing organised crime.
Tags
- #INTERPOL
- #Organized Crime
- #Red Notice
- #I-24/7
- #International Police Cooperation
- #Transnational Crime
- #Operation Pangea
- #NCB Islamabad
- #FIA
- #CSS Criminology 2018
- #csssolvedpapers
- #csssolvedpapers2018
- #CSS Criminology Solved Paper 2018
- #To what extent Interpol has been successful in
This topic in other CSS papers
Examiners return to the same themes. Compare how the question was framed in other years.
- CSS 2020 · Q. 7The International Criminal Police Organization (ICPO-INTERPOL) was founded in 1914 with the founding principle to coordinate efforts relating to international police cooperation. How do you see the role of INTERPOL for reducing money laundering with special reference to Pakistan?Common topic: FIA, INTERPOL
- CSS 2024 · Q. 7Provide an overview of the International Police Association (IPA). What is its mission, and how does it contribute to international police relations?Common topic: International Police Cooperation, INTERPOL
- CSS 2022 · Q. 9Discuss the role of FIA in controlling organized crimes in Pakistan.Common topic: Organized Crime, INTERPOL
- CSS 2021 · Q. 7What is the difference between EUROPOL and INTERPOL? How does EUROPOL assist Member states investigation to control terrorist networks in Europe?Common topic: International Police Cooperation, INTERPOL
- CSS 2016 · Q. 4Write a note on the role of Crime Control Agencies.Common topic: FIA
Browse every CSS Criminology solved past paper or the full library of CSS solved past papers, and compare with the original CSS 2018 Criminology question paper.
Answered this question differently?
Submit your own answer — approved answers are published with your name.
Get new solved papers on WhatsApp
Follow the CSS Nexus channel to hear first when new answers are published.

Corrections and discussion
Nothing here yet. Spotted a mistake in this answer, or have a suggestion? Tell us below.