CSS NEXUS
CSS Solved Criminology

CSS 2018CriminologyQ. 3

What is the Islamic perspective on crime and punishment? Explain your answer with the help of proper examples.

By CSS Nexus Team ·

Original CSS 2016–2026 Criminology paper

This answer to the CSS 2018 Criminology paper (Q. 3) was written by the CSS Nexus team. Read the outline first, then see how each point is developed.

Outline

  • 1. Introduction
  • 2. Overview: the concept of crime in Islam
  • 3. Islamic perspective on crime
  • ✓Crime as violation of divine law; protection of five objectives; individual responsibility; intention; prevention through faith; social justice; family and community; equality before law
  • 4. Islamic perspective on punishment with examples
  • ✓Hudud; qisas; diyat and forgiveness; tazir; strict standards of proof; doubt averts punishment; repentance and reform; deterrence and justice
  • 5. Islamic criminal law in Pakistan
  • 6. Misconceptions and critical view
  • 7. Conclusion

Answer

Introduction

The Holy Quran declares that "whoever kills a soul unless for a soul or for corruption [done] in the land, it is as if he had slain mankind entirely. And whoever saves one, it is as if he had saved mankind entirely" (Al-Ma'idah 5:32). This verse sums up the Islamic view: crime is an attack on society as a whole, and the law exists to protect human life and dignity. Islamic criminal law is often reduced to its punishments, but its real emphasis is on preventing crime through faith, justice and social welfare, with punishment as a last resort.

Overview

In Islamic law (Shariah), crime (jarimah) is an act prohibited by Allah for which a punishment is prescribed. Jurists divide crimes into three categories: hudud (fixed punishments set by the Quran or Sunnah), qisas and diyat (retaliation or compensation for murder and bodily harm, where the victim's family has rights) and ta'zir (discretionary punishments decided by the state for all other wrongs). Classical scholars such as Imam al-Ghazali and Imam al-Shatibi explained that the purpose of the Shariah (maqasid al-Shariah) is to protect five essentials: religion, life, intellect, lineage and property.

Categories of crime in Islam

  • Hudud
  • Qisas and diyat
  • Ta'zir

Islamic perspective on crime

1. Crime as a violation of divine and social order.

A crime offends both Allah's commands and the rights of people (huquq al-ibad). The Quran commands justice and forbids "immorality and bad conduct and oppression" (An-Nahl 16:90). (Reference: Quran 16:90; Mohammad Hashim Kamali, Shari'ah Law: An Introduction, Oneworld, 2008.)

2. Protection of the five objectives.

Each major crime threatens one essential: murder threatens life, drinking threatens intellect, adultery threatens lineage, theft threatens property and apostasy-related offences were linked to religion. Punishments protect these values. (Reference: Al-Shatibi, Al-Muwafaqat; Kamali, Shari'ah Law.)

3. Individual responsibility.

Every person is accountable for his own acts; "no bearer of burdens will bear the burden of another" (Al-An'am 6:164). Collective punishment of a family or tribe is not allowed. (Reference: Quran 6:164.)

4. Role of intention.

Liability depends on intention and capacity. The Prophet (PBUH) said that the pen is lifted from the sleeper, the child until puberty and the insane until he recovers. (Reference: Sunan Abi Dawud 4403; Sunan Ibn Majah 2041.)

5. Prevention through faith and morality.

Islam seeks to stop crime at its root through belief in accountability on the Day of Judgement, prayer and moral training; the Quran says prayer "prohibits immorality and wrongdoing" (Al-Ankabut 29:45). (Reference: Quran 29:45.)

6. Social and economic justice.

Zakat, charity and the duty of the state to meet basic needs reduce poverty-driven crime. Hazrat Umar (RA) suspended the hand-cutting punishment during the famine year (Am al-Ramadah, 18 AH) because need created doubt. (Reference: Quran 9:60; Ibn Qudamah, Al-Mughni, chapter on theft.)

7. Family and community responsibility.

Strong families, modesty rules and the duty of enjoining good and forbidding evil make the community a guardian against crime. (Reference: Quran 3:104; Kamali, Shari'ah Law.)

8. Equality before the law.

When influential people sought to save a noblewoman of Banu Makhzum from punishment for theft, the Prophet (PBUH) said that earlier nations were destroyed because they punished the poor and spared the rich, and that he would punish even his own daughter Fatimah. (Reference: Sahih al-Bukhari 6787-6788.)

Islamic view of crime

  • 01Divine and social order
  • 02Five objectives
  • 03Individual responsibility
  • 04Intention
  • 05Faith and morality
  • 06Social justice
  • 07Community role
  • 08Equality before law

Islamic perspective on punishment with examples

1. Hudud: fixed punishments.

Examples are amputation for theft that meets strict conditions (Al-Ma'idah 5:38), a hundred lashes for unmarried persons guilty of zina (An-Nur 24:2), eighty lashes for false accusation of unchastity, qazf (An-Nur 24:4), and severe penalties for hirabah, armed robbery and spreading terror (Al-Ma'idah 5:33). (Reference: Quran 5:33, 5:38, 24:2, 24:4.)

2. Qisas: equal retaliation.

For intentional murder or injury, the victim's heirs may demand equal retribution. The Quran says, "there is for you in legal retribution [saving of] life" (Al-Baqarah 2:179), because the certainty of retribution deters killing. (Reference: Quran 2:178-179.)

3. Diyat and forgiveness.

The heirs may instead accept blood money (diyat) or forgive, and forgiveness is praised (Al-Baqarah 2:178). For accidental killing, diyat and expiation are required (An-Nisa 4:92). (Reference: Quran 2:178, 4:92.)

4. Ta'zir: discretionary punishment.

For crimes not covered by hudud or qisas, such as bribery, fraud, smuggling or cybercrime, the state may set punishments such as imprisonment, fines or warnings according to public interest. (Reference: Ibn Taymiyyah, Al-Siyasah al-Shar'iyyah; Kamali, Shari'ah Law.)

5. Strict standards of proof.

Hudud require confession or strong evidence; zina requires four eyewitnesses to the act, which makes punishment rare and protects privacy. (Reference: Quran 24:4 and 24:13; M. Cherif Bassiouni (ed.), The Islamic Criminal Justice System, Oceana, 1982.)

6. Doubt averts punishment.

Jurists adopted the maxim that hudud are averted by doubt (shubhah). Hazrat Umar's suspension of the theft penalty in famine is a classic example. (Reference: Ibn Qudamah, Al-Mughni; Kamali, Punishment in Islamic Law: An Enquiry into the Hudud Bill of Kelantan, Ilmiah, 1995.)

7. Repentance and reform.

The Quran exempts those who repent before being caught in hirabah (Al-Ma'idah 5:34) and repeatedly calls for repentance, showing that reform is valued. (Reference: Quran 5:34; 5:39.)

8. Deterrence, justice and public punishment.

Punishments aim to deter ("as a deterrent from Allah", Al-Ma'idah 5:38) and to restore justice to victims; public execution of punishment was meant to warn society (An-Nur 24:2). (Reference: Quran 5:38, 24:2; Kamali, Shari'ah Law.)

Punishment in Islam

  1. 1

    Hudud

  2. 2

    Qisas

  3. 3

    Diyat and forgiveness

  4. 4

    Ta'zir

  5. 5

    Strict proof

  6. 6

    Doubt averts punishment

  7. 7

    Repentance

  8. 8

    Deterrence and justice

Islamic criminal law in Pakistan

Pakistan introduced the Hudood Ordinances in 1979 (on zina, theft, qazf and alcohol) and the Qisas and Diyat Ordinance in 1990, enacted as the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act 1997. The Federal Shariat Court (Article 203D) can strike down laws repugnant to Islam. The Protection of Women (Criminal Laws Amendment) Act 2006 moved rape back into the PPC because the four-witness requirement had led to rape victims being charged with zina. Hudd punishments such as amputation have rarely, if ever, been carried out, and most convictions are under ta'zir.

Misconceptions and critical view

Critics see Islamic punishments only as harsh. Islamic scholars reply that the strict conditions make hudud rare, that the system's main goals are prevention and social justice, and that the punishments presuppose a just society where basic needs are met. Problems arise when laws are applied without these safeguards, or when the qisas and diyat law allows influential families to pardon killers of their own relatives, a loophole Pakistan partly closed for honour killings in 2016.

Conclusion

The Quran's statement that "in legal retribution there is life" captures the Islamic logic: punishment exists to protect life and society, not to take revenge. Islam combines prevention through faith, family and social justice with deterrent punishments, strict proof, mercy and repentance. Applied in its true spirit, as the example of Hazrat Umar shows, the Islamic perspective offers a balanced model of crime control that values both justice and compassion.

Tags

Browse every CSS Criminology solved past paper or the full library of CSS solved past papers, and compare with the original CSS 2018 Criminology question paper.

Corrections and discussion

Nothing here yet. Spotted a mistake in this answer, or have a suggestion? Tell us below.

Add your comment, correction or suggestion

Everything is checked by our team before it appears. Please keep it respectful and on topic.

Your rating (optional)

Answered this question differently?

Submit your own answer — approved answers are published with your name.

Submit your answer

Get new solved papers on WhatsApp

Follow the CSS Nexus channel to hear first when new answers are published.

Follow our WhatsApp channel

More solved Criminology

CSS 2022CriminologyQ. 6

What are the legal and ethical guidelines for investigating gender-based crimes? Explain your answer with the help of suitable examples.

#cssnexus #Gender-Based Crimes #Sexual Violence Investigation #Anti-Rape Act 2021

CSS Nexus21 Nov 2026
CSS 2020CriminologyQ. 6

Define criminal investigation and its principles. Highlight with examples the importance of modern techniques used for crime detection in Pakistan.

#cssnexus #Criminal Investigation #Modern Investigation Techniques #Geo-fencing

CSS Nexus21 Nov 2026