CSS NEXUS
CSS Solved Criminology

CSS 2023CriminologyQ. 5

What challenges are faced by police in controlling crime and maintaining law and order in the country?

By CSS Nexus Team ·

Original CSS 2023 Criminology paper Original CSS 2016–2026 Criminology paper

This answer to the CSS 2023 Criminology paper (Q. 5) was written by the CSS Nexus team. Read the outline first, then see how each point is developed.

Outline

  • 1. Introduction
  • 2. Overview: the police and law and order in Pakistan
  • 3. Challenges faced by the police
  • ✓Political interference; shortage of manpower; poor resources and pay; outdated laws and structures; weak investigation and forensics; corruption and abuse; terrorism and militancy; lack of public trust
  • 4. Way forward
  • ✓Depoliticisation; more personnel; better pay and welfare; legal reform; investigation and forensics; accountability; counter-terrorism capacity; community policing
  • 5. Conclusion

Answer

Introduction

The Pakistani police are expected to fight terrorists, control street crime, manage protests, protect VIPs and investigate thousands of cases, often with colonial-era laws, limited resources and political pressure. Lord Acton's warning that "power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely" applies to a police force that successive governments have often used as a political instrument rather than allowing it to serve as a professional service. Understanding these challenges is the first step towards meaningful reform.

Overview

Law and order is a provincial subject after the 18th Amendment (2010), and each province has its own police force under laws such as the Police Order 2002 or the KP Police Act 2017. Pakistan has roughly one police officer for every 500-600 people, below the UN-recommended ratio of about 1:450, and many personnel are deployed on VIP and protest duty rather than crime control. Terrorism has also forced the police to perform paramilitary roles: hundreds of policemen have been killed in attacks, especially in Khyber Pakhtunkhwa.

Pressures on the police

  1. Rising crime
  2. Terrorism
  3. Political demands
  4. Limited resources
  5. Weak law enforcement

Challenges faced by the police

1. Political interference.

Postings, transfers and promotions are often decided by politicians, who use the police to protect allies and target opponents, undermining professionalism. (Reference: International Crisis Group, Reforming Pakistan's Police, Asia Report No. 157, 2008.)

2. Shortage of manpower.

Police strength has not kept pace with population growth and urbanisation, and a large share of officers is assigned to VIP security. (Reference: Hassan Abbas, Stabilizing Pakistan through Police Reform, Asia Society, 2012.)

3. Poor resources and pay.

Inadequate vehicles, fuel, communication equipment and investigation budgets, along with long duty hours and low pay, reduce efficiency and morale. (Reference: Abbas, 2012; Senate Standing Committee reports on police welfare.)

4. Outdated laws and structures.

The Police Act 1861, Police Rules 1934 and CrPC 1898 remain in force in parts of the country, and reforms under the Police Order 2002 have been unevenly implemented. (Reference: Police Act 1861; Police Order 2002.)

5. Weak investigation and forensics.

Investigating officers lack training and forensic support, leading to reliance on confessions and low conviction rates. (Reference: Law and Justice Commission of Pakistan reports; Punjab Forensic Science Agency.)

6. Corruption and abuse of power.

Bribery, fake encounters, illegal detention and torture damage the police's credibility. (Reference: Transparency International Pakistan, National Corruption Perception Survey 2023; HRCP, State of Human Rights reports.)

7. Terrorism and militancy.

Police stations and personnel are frequent targets, as in the attack on the Karachi Police Office (February 2023) and the Peshawar Police Lines mosque bombing (January 2023), which killed about 100 people. (Reference: Pakistan Institute for Peace Studies, Pakistan Security Report 2023.)

8. Lack of public trust.

Fear and distrust of the police discourage citizens from reporting crime and giving evidence, weakening crime control. (Reference: Gallup Pakistan surveys on police trust; Tom R. Tyler, Why People Obey the Law, Princeton University Press, 2006.)

Police challenges

  • Political interference
  • Manpower shortage
  • Poor resources
  • Outdated laws
  • Weak investigation
  • Corruption
  • Terrorism
  • Low public trust

Way forward

1. Depoliticisation.

Fixed tenures, merit-based postings and independent public safety commissions, as provided in the Police Order 2002 and KP Police Act 2017. (Reference: Khyber Pakhtunkhwa Police Act 2017.)

2. More personnel.

Recruitment to reach international ratios and freeing police from VIP duties. (Reference: ICG, 2008.)

3. Better pay and welfare.

Improved salaries, housing, health care and fixed working hours. (Reference: Abbas, 2012.)

4. Legal reform.

Replacing colonial laws and implementing the Police Order 2002 fully across provinces. (Reference: Police Order 2002.)

5. Investigation and forensics.

Separate investigation cadres, training and forensic labs in every division. (Reference: Punjab Forensic Science Agency Act 2007.)

6. Accountability.

Independent complaint authorities, CCTV in stations and enforcement of the anti-torture law. (Reference: Torture and Custodial Death (Prevention and Punishment) Act 2022.)

7. Counter-terrorism capacity.

Well-equipped CTDs, intelligence sharing and protection of police installations. (Reference: NACTA, National Internal Security Policy 2018-23.)

8. Community policing.

Partnerships with citizens, CPLC-type committees and dispute resolution councils to rebuild trust. (Reference: Citizens-Police Liaison Committee Karachi; KP Dispute Resolution Councils.)

Way forward

  • 01Depoliticise
  • 02More personnel
  • 03Better pay
  • 04Legal reform
  • 05Investigation and forensics
  • 06Accountability
  • 07CT capacity
  • 08Community policing

Conclusion

As Sir Robert Peel observed, "the ability of the police to perform their duties is dependent upon public approval of police actions." Pakistan's police face political interference, shortages, outdated laws, weak investigation, corruption and terrorism, all of which erode public approval. Reform that makes the police professional, accountable and close to the people is essential for controlling crime and maintaining law and order.

Tags

This topic in other CSS papers

Examiners return to the same themes. Compare how the question was framed in other years.

Browse every CSS Criminology solved past paper or the full library of CSS solved past papers, and compare with the original CSS 2023 Criminology question paper.

Corrections and discussion

Nothing here yet. Spotted a mistake in this answer, or have a suggestion? Tell us below.

Add your comment, correction or suggestion

Everything is checked by our team before it appears. Please keep it respectful and on topic.

Your rating (optional)

Answered this question differently?

Submit your own answer — approved answers are published with your name.

Submit your answer

Get new solved papers on WhatsApp

Follow the CSS Nexus channel to hear first when new answers are published.

Follow our WhatsApp channel

More solved Criminology

CSS Special 2023Criminology2023

Evaluate the efficacy of the investigation processes being practiced in Pakistan, adding suggestions for improvement therein.

#cssnexus #Criminal Investigation #Police Investigation in Pakistan #Conviction Rate

CSS Nexus21 Nov 2026
CSS 2023CriminologyQ. 8

'Terrorism and radicalization continue to pose threat to global peace, economy and stability'. Discuss.

#cssnexus #Terrorism #Radicalisation #Global Peace

CSS Nexus21 Nov 2026
CSS 2020CriminologyQ. 9

Keeping in view the social learning perspective in criminology, discuss how terrorists use internet as a tool to reinforce their ideology among youth in Pakistan.

#cssnexus #Social Learning Theory #Ronald Akers #Online Radicalisation

CSS Nexus21 Nov 2026