CSS 2019CriminologyQ. 2
Travis Hirschi argued that crime results when an individual's bond to society is weak or broken. Discuss in detail what this theory of social bonding explains about crime.
#cssnexusBy CSS Nexus Team ·
This answer to the CSS 2019 Criminology paper (Q. 2) was written by the CSS Nexus team. Read the outline first, then see how each point is developed.
Outline
- 1. Introduction
- 2. Overview: background of control theory
- 3. The four elements of the social bond
- ✓Attachment; commitment; involvement; belief
- 4. What social bond theory explains about crime
- ✓Why most people conform; role of family; school and delinquency; peers; age and crime; gender differences; effect of social change; policy implications
- 5. Critical evaluation
- 6. Relevance to Pakistan
- 7. Conclusion
Answer
Introduction
Most criminological theories ask, "Why do people commit crime?" Travis Hirschi turned the question around. In Causes of Delinquency (1969) he asked, "Why do men obey the rules of society?" His answer was that "delinquent acts result when an individual's bond to society is weak or broken." People are naturally capable of breaking rules; what holds them back is their connection to family, school, work and moral values. When these bonds weaken, crime becomes more likely.
Overview
Hirschi's theory belongs to the control tradition, which assumes that the motivation for crime is common and that the real question is what restrains people. Earlier control theorists included Albert Reiss (1951), who spoke of personal and social controls; F. Ivan Nye (1958), who emphasised family controls; and Walter Reckless (1961), whose containment theory described inner and outer containments. Hirschi tested his theory with a survey of about 4,000 school students in Richmond, California, finding that students with strong attachments to parents and school reported less delinquency.
Roots of control theory
- Reiss (1951)
- Nye (1958)
- Reckless's containment (1961)
- Hirschi's social bond (1969)
- Self-control theory (1990)
The four elements of the social bond
1. Attachment.
Emotional ties to others, especially parents, teachers and friends, make people care about their opinions. A child who loves his parents avoids actions that would hurt or shame them. Hirschi considered attachment the most important element. (Reference: Travis Hirschi, Causes of Delinquency, University of California Press, 1969, ch. 2.)
2. Commitment.
Investment in conventional goals such as education, career and reputation gives people something to lose. A student aiming for a scholarship or a job in the civil service is less likely to risk it through crime. (Reference: Hirschi, Causes of Delinquency, ch. 2.)
3. Involvement.
Time spent in conventional activities, such as study, sports, work and religious activity, leaves less time and opportunity for delinquency, reflecting the idea that "idle hands are the devil's workshop." (Reference: Hirschi, Causes of Delinquency.)
4. Belief.
Acceptance of society's moral values and respect for law restrain behaviour; where belief in the rules is weak, people feel freer to break them. (Reference: Hirschi, Causes of Delinquency; Ronald L. Akers and Christine S. Sellers, Criminological Theories, 7th ed., Oxford University Press, 2017.)
Elements of the social bond
- 01Attachment
- 02Commitment
- 03Involvement
- 04Belief
What social bond theory explains about crime
1. Why most people conform.
The theory explains conformity as the normal result of strong bonds, rather than treating crime as abnormal behaviour needing a special motive. (Reference: Francis T. Cullen and Robert Agnew, Criminological Theory: Past to Present, 6th ed., Oxford University Press, 2017.)
2. The role of the family.
Weak parental attachment, poor supervision and family conflict are strongly linked to delinquency, as many studies confirm. (Reference: Rolf Loeber and Magda Stouthamer-Loeber, "Family Factors as Correlates and Predictors of Juvenile Conduct Problems", Crime and Justice, vol. 7, 1986.)
3. School and delinquency.
Students who dislike school, perform poorly and drop out have weaker commitment and are more delinquent. (Reference: Hirschi, Causes of Delinquency, ch. 7.)
4. Peers.
Hirschi found that youths with strong conventional bonds were less influenced by delinquent friends, although later research shows peers matter more than he expected. (Reference: Mark Warr, Companions in Crime, Cambridge University Press, 2002.)
5. Age and crime.
Offending peaks in adolescence, when bonds to parents loosen and commitments to work and family are not yet formed, and declines as adults form new bonds. (Reference: Robert J. Sampson and John H. Laub, Crime in the Making, Harvard University Press, 1993.)
6. Gender differences.
Girls are generally more closely supervised and attached, which partly explains their lower offending. (Reference: John Hagan, Structural Criminology, Rutgers University Press, 1989.)
7. Effects of social change.
Urbanisation, migration and family breakdown weaken traditional bonds, which can explain rising crime in rapidly changing societies. (Reference: Émile Durkheim, Suicide, 1897 (on weakening social integration); Akers and Sellers, 2017.)
8. Policy implications.
The theory supports prevention through strengthening families, keeping children in school, providing extracurricular activities and promoting respect for law. (Reference: Lawrence W. Sherman et al., Preventing Crime: What Works, US DOJ, 1997.)
What the theory explains
- 1
Conformity
- 2
Family
- 3
School
- 4
Peers
- 5
Age
- 6
Gender
- 7
Social change
- 8
Prevention policy
Critical evaluation
Social bond theory is one of the most tested theories in criminology, and attachment and commitment consistently predict lower delinquency. Critics, however, point out that it explains minor delinquency better than serious crime, assumes bonds always point towards conformity (a youth can be strongly attached to a criminal father or gang), underestimates the role of peers and says little about why bonds weaken in the first place. Hirschi himself later developed, with Michael Gottfredson, the self-control theory (A General Theory of Crime, 1990), arguing that low self-control formed in childhood is the main cause of crime.
Relevance to Pakistan
In Pakistan, strong joint family systems and religious values have traditionally provided powerful bonds. Rapid urbanisation, migration of fathers abroad, school dropout and unemployment are weakening these bonds, especially among urban youth. Strengthening family support, universal education, sports and youth programmes, and respect for the law, as the theory suggests, would help prevent delinquency.
Conclusion
Hirschi's insight that "delinquent acts result when an individual's bond to society is weak or broken" shifts attention from the criminal's motives to society's ties. Attachment, commitment, involvement and belief explain why most people obey the law and why some do not. For policy, the lesson is clear: building strong families, schools and communities is the most natural and lasting form of crime prevention.
Tags
- #Social Bond Theory
- #Travis Hirschi
- #Social Control Theory
- #Attachment
- #Commitment
- #Involvement
- #Belief
- #Juvenile Delinquency
- #Criminological Theory
- #CSS Criminology 2019
- #csssolvedpapers
- #csssolvedpapers2019
- #CSS Criminology Solved Paper 2019
- #Travis Hirschi argued that crime results when an
- #Discuss in detail what this theory of social
Browse every CSS Criminology solved past paper or the full library of CSS solved past papers, and compare with the original CSS 2019 Criminology question paper.
Answered this question differently?
Submit your own answer — approved answers are published with your name.
Get new solved papers on WhatsApp
Follow the CSS Nexus channel to hear first when new answers are published.

Corrections and discussion
Nothing here yet. Spotted a mistake in this answer, or have a suggestion? Tell us below.