CSS NEXUS
CSS Solved Criminology

CSS 2019CriminologyQ. 3

Discuss the fundamental postulates of Edwin Sutherland's 'Differential Association theory' with examples.

By CSS Nexus Team ·

Original CSS 2016–2026 Criminology paper

This answer to the CSS 2019 Criminology paper (Q. 3) was written by the CSS Nexus team. Read the outline first, then see how each point is developed.

Outline

  • 1. Introduction
  • 2. Overview: background of the theory
  • 3. The nine postulates of differential association, with examples
  • ✓Learned; interaction; intimate groups; techniques and motives; definitions of law; excess of definitions; frequency, duration, priority and intensity; same mechanisms as other learning; not explained by general needs
  • 4. Strengths of the theory
  • 5. Criticisms and later developments
  • 6. Relevance to Pakistan
  • 7. Conclusion

Answer

Introduction

Edwin H. Sutherland, often called the dean of American criminology, rejected the idea that criminals are born or mentally abnormal. In his Principles of Criminology (third edition, 1939, final form 1947) he declared that "criminal behavior is learned." His differential association theory argues that people learn crime in the same way they learn any other behaviour: through interaction with others who hold attitudes favourable to breaking the law. It remains one of the most influential sociological theories of crime.

Overview

Sutherland developed the theory partly from his studies of professional thieves and later of white-collar crime. He noticed that crime was common among respectable businessmen who were neither poor nor biologically abnormal, which theories based on poverty or defects could not explain. Crime, he concluded, depends on the balance of "definitions" a person learns: messages favourable or unfavourable to violating the law. The theory influenced later social learning approaches, especially Ronald Akers' social learning theory.

Development of the theory

  1. Professional thieves study (1937)
  2. Principles of Criminology (1939)
  3. Final nine postulates (1947)
  4. White Collar Crime (1949)
  5. Akers' social learning theory

The nine postulates of differential association, with examples

1. Criminal behaviour is learned.

Crime is not inherited or invented; a person who has never been exposed to crime does not invent it. Example: a boy does not know how to pick a lock or start a car without its key unless someone teaches him. (Reference: Edwin H. Sutherland and Donald R. Cressey, Principles of Criminology, 10th ed., Lippincott, 1978, ch. 4.)

2. It is learned in interaction with other persons through communication.

Learning happens through words and gestures in social contact. Example: a young man learns from an older relative how to smuggle goods across a border by talking and watching. (Reference: Sutherland and Cressey, 1978.)

3. The principal part of learning occurs within intimate personal groups.

Family, friends and close peers matter far more than films or newspapers. Example: a teenager in a street gang in Lyari learns attitudes towards violence from gang members he trusts. (Reference: Sutherland and Cressey, 1978; Mark Warr, Companions in Crime, Cambridge University Press, 2002.)

4. Learning includes techniques and motives, drives, rationalisations and attitudes.

People learn both how to commit crime and why it is acceptable. Example: a new bank employee learns from colleagues how to manipulate loan papers and also the excuse that "everyone does it." (Reference: Sutherland, White Collar Crime, Dryden Press, 1949.)

5. The direction of motives and drives is learned from definitions of legal codes as favourable or unfavourable. In some groups, laws are seen as rules to obey; in others, as obstacles to evade. Example: in a community where tax evasion is admired as smartness, people learn to see tax laws negatively. (Reference: Sutherland and Cressey, 1978.)

6. A person becomes delinquent because of an excess of definitions favourable to violation of law over definitions unfavourable to it. This is the core principle. Example: a youth hears more praise for "easy money" from drug peddlers than warnings from parents and teachers, and so turns to peddling. (Reference: Sutherland and Cressey, 1978; Ronald L. Akers and Christine S. Sellers, Criminological Theories, 7th ed., Oxford University Press, 2017.)

7. Differential associations vary in frequency, duration, priority and intensity.

Associations that occur often, last long, begin early in life and involve respected persons have the greatest effect. Example: a child exposed from early age to a respected uncle involved in land grabbing is more influenced than by a brief encounter with a stranger. (Reference: Sutherland and Cressey, 1978.)

8. Learning criminal behaviour involves all the mechanisms involved in any other learning. Imitation, reinforcement and practice apply to crime as to any skill. Example: a pickpocket improves by practice and is rewarded by successful thefts, just as an apprentice improves a trade. (Reference: Sutherland and Cressey, 1978; Robert L. Burgess and Ronald L. Akers, "A Differential Association-Reinforcement Theory of Criminal Behavior", Social Problems, vol. 14, 1966.)

9. Criminal behaviour is not explained by general needs and values, because non-criminal behaviour expresses the same needs. Both a thief and an honest worker want money; the need does not explain the choice. Example: two poor brothers both need money, but one becomes a labourer and the other a robber because of the different associations they formed. (Reference: Sutherland and Cressey, 1978.)

Nine postulates

  • Crime is learned
  • Learned by interaction
  • Intimate groups
  • Techniques and motives
  • Definitions of law
  • Excess of definitions
  • Frequency, duration, priority, intensity
  • Normal learning processes
  • Not explained by needs

Strengths of the theory

The theory explains crime across social classes, including white-collar crime; it highlights the role of peers and family, strongly supported by research; it moved criminology away from biological explanations; and it suggests practical remedies, such as separating first offenders from hardened criminals and providing positive role models.

Criticisms and later developments

Critics argue that the theory is hard to test because "definitions" cannot easily be measured; it does not explain impulsive crimes or crimes by people with no criminal contacts; it ignores individual differences in why some people exposed to crime resist it; and it does not explain where criminal definitions come from in the first place. Burgess and Akers (1966) and later Akers' social learning theory added reinforcement and imitation, making the theory more testable, while Sykes and Matza's techniques of neutralisation (1957) explained how offenders justify their actions.

Relevance to Pakistan

The theory helps explain why first-time offenders who are jailed with hardened criminals often come out more criminal, a strong argument for separating under-trial and juvenile prisoners. It also explains how corruption spreads in departments where it is seen as normal, how street gangs and militant groups recruit through friendship and kinship networks, and why positive role models and community programmes matter for youth.

Conclusion

Sutherland's simple statement that "criminal behavior is learned" changed criminology. The nine postulates show that crime is learned in close groups through communication, techniques and attitudes, and that people offend when definitions favourable to crime outweigh those against it. The practical lesson for Pakistan is to control what young people learn and from whom: strong families, good schools, positive peers and prisons that do not become schools of crime.

Tags

This topic in other CSS papers

Examiners return to the same themes. Compare how the question was framed in other years.

Browse every CSS Criminology solved past paper or the full library of CSS solved past papers, and compare with the original CSS 2019 Criminology question paper.

Corrections and discussion

Nothing here yet. Spotted a mistake in this answer, or have a suggestion? Tell us below.

Add your comment, correction or suggestion

Everything is checked by our team before it appears. Please keep it respectful and on topic.

Your rating (optional)

Answered this question differently?

Submit your own answer — approved answers are published with your name.

Submit your answer

Get new solved papers on WhatsApp

Follow the CSS Nexus channel to hear first when new answers are published.

Follow our WhatsApp channel

More solved Criminology

CSS 2020CriminologyQ. 9

Keeping in view the social learning perspective in criminology, discuss how terrorists use internet as a tool to reinforce their ideology among youth in Pakistan.

#cssnexus #Social Learning Theory #Ronald Akers #Online Radicalisation

CSS Nexus21 Nov 2026
CSS 2016CriminologyQ. 3

Define the term Crime and Criminals. Explain the types of Criminals in detail.

#cssnexus #Definition of Crime #Criminal #Types of Criminals

CSS Nexus21 Nov 2026