CSS 2020CriminologyQ. 3
What is your position on the nature vs nurture debate in criminology?
#cssnexusBy CSS Nexus Team ·
This answer to the CSS 2020 Criminology paper (Q. 3) was written by the CSS Nexus team. Read the outline first, then see how each point is developed.
Outline
- 1. Introduction
- 2. Overview: the debate in criminology
- 3. Arguments for nature
- ✓Twin studies; adoption studies; MAOA and gene-environment interaction; brain structure; neurochemistry; temperament and low self-control; prenatal factors; heritability of antisocial behaviour
- 4. Arguments for nurture
- ✓Family; poverty and inequality; neighbourhood; peers; schooling; exposure to violence; culture; changing crime rates
- 5. My position: interaction, not opposition
- 6. Implications for Pakistan
- 7. Conclusion
Answer
Introduction
The psychologist Donald Hebb was once asked which contributes more to personality, nature or nurture. He replied that it was like asking which contributes more to the area of a rectangle, its length or its width. The same is true of crime. Since Lombroso's claim of the "born criminal" and Sutherland's reply that crime is learned, criminology has debated whether criminal behaviour comes from biology (nature) or environment (nurture). My position is that crime results from the interaction of both, with environment playing the decisive role in most cases.
Overview
The nature side holds that genes, brain structure and biochemistry predispose some individuals to aggression, impulsivity or antisocial behaviour. The nurture side holds that family, poverty, peers, neighbourhoods and culture shape behaviour. Early biological theories were discredited for their racism and poor methods, and sociological theories dominated the twentieth century. Since the 1990s, biosocial criminology has revived interest in biology, but now in terms of gene-environment interaction rather than determinism.
Course of the debate
- Lombroso's born criminal
- Sutherland's learned crime
- Sociological dominance
- Twin and adoption studies
- Biosocial criminology
Arguments for nature
1. Twin studies.
Identical twins share more antisocial behaviour than fraternal twins, suggesting a genetic contribution. A meta-analysis estimated heritability of antisocial behaviour at about 41%. (Reference: Soo Hyun Rhee and Irwin D. Waldman, "Genetic and Environmental Influences on Antisocial Behavior: A Meta-Analysis", Psychological Bulletin, vol. 128, 2002.)
2. Adoption studies.
In a Danish study of over 14,000 adoptees, sons whose biological parents had criminal records were more likely to have convictions, even when raised by non-criminal adoptive parents. (Reference: Sarnoff A. Mednick, William F. Gabrielli and Barry Hutchings, "Genetic Influences in Criminal Convictions", Science, vol. 224, 1984.)
3. The MAOA gene and gene-environment interaction.
Boys with a low-activity version of the MAOA gene who were maltreated in childhood were far more likely to become violent, showing how genes interact with environment. (Reference: Avshalom Caspi et al., "Role of Genotype in the Cycle of Violence in Maltreated Children", Science, vol. 297, 2002.)
4. Brain structure and function.
Brain imaging shows reduced activity in the prefrontal cortex, which controls impulses, among some violent offenders. (Reference: Adrian Raine, The Anatomy of Violence, Pantheon, 2013.)
5. Neurochemistry and hormones.
Low serotonin and high testosterone have been associated with impulsive aggression. (Reference: Raine, The Anatomy of Violence.)
6. Temperament and low self-control.
Difficult temperament and impulsivity, partly inherited, appear early in childhood and predict later offending. (Reference: Terrie E. Moffitt, "Adolescence-Limited and Life-Course-Persistent Antisocial Behavior", Psychological Review, vol. 100, 1993.)
7. Prenatal and early health factors.
Birth complications, maternal smoking, malnutrition and lead exposure affect brain development and are linked to later delinquency. (Reference: Adrian Raine, Patricia Brennan and Sarnoff A. Mednick, "Birth Complications Combined with Early Maternal Rejection", Archives of General Psychiatry, vol. 51, 1994.)
8. Persistent offenders.
A small group of life-course-persistent offenders, showing problems from early childhood, suggests underlying neuropsychological deficits. (Reference: Moffitt, 1993.)
Evidence for nature
- Twin studies
- Adoption studies
- MAOA gene
- Brain function
- Neurochemistry
- Temperament
- Prenatal factors
- Persistent offenders
Arguments for nurture
1. Family environment.
Poor parenting, neglect, abuse and family conflict are among the strongest predictors of delinquency. (Reference: Rolf Loeber and Magda Stouthamer-Loeber, "Family Factors as Correlates and Predictors of Juvenile Conduct Problems", Crime and Justice, vol. 7, 1986.)
2. Poverty and inequality.
Crime rates are higher where poverty and inequality are greater, as strain theory explains. (Reference: Robert K. Merton, "Social Structure and Anomie", American Sociological Review, vol. 3, 1938.)
3. Neighbourhood.
Disorganised neighbourhoods with weak community control produce high crime regardless of which group lives there. (Reference: Clifford R. Shaw and Henry D. McKay, Juvenile Delinquency and Urban Areas, 1942.)
4. Peers.
Association with delinquent friends is one of the strongest correlates of offending. (Reference: Mark Warr, Companions in Crime, Cambridge University Press, 2002.)
5. Schooling.
School failure and dropout increase delinquency, while engagement in school protects. (Reference: Travis Hirschi, Causes of Delinquency, 1969.)
6. Exposure to violence.
Children who witness or suffer violence are more likely to become violent, as the "cycle of violence" research shows. (Reference: Cathy Spatz Widom, "The Cycle of Violence", Science, vol. 244, 1989.)
7. Culture and norms.
Cultures of honour or subcultures that approve violence raise violent crime, independent of biology. (Reference: Richard E. Nisbett and Dov Cohen, Culture of Honor, Westview Press, 1996.)
8. Rapid changes in crime rates.
Crime rates rise and fall sharply within a generation, which genes cannot explain, pointing to social and economic causes. (Reference: Franklin E. Zimring, The Great American Crime Decline, Oxford University Press, 2007.)
Evidence for nurture
- 01Family
- 02Poverty
- 03Neighbourhood
- 04Peers
- 05School
- 06Exposure to violence
- 07Culture
- 08Changing crime rates
My position: interaction, not opposition
The evidence supports an interactionist position. Biology can create predispositions, such as impulsivity or low fear, but whether they lead to crime depends heavily on environment. Caspi's MAOA study shows this clearly: the genetic risk mattered mainly for maltreated children. Genes are not destiny; a child with a difficult temperament raised in a loving family, good school and safe neighbourhood usually does not become a criminal. At the same time, ignoring biology would overlook factors such as brain injury, lead exposure, malnutrition and mental disorder that can be treated. Because environment is both more powerful for most offenders and more open to change, crime policy should give priority to nurture while using biological knowledge for early health and treatment.
Implications for Pakistan
In Pakistan, nurture factors such as poverty, child labour, school dropout, family violence and drug abuse dominate the risk of delinquency. Biological insights also matter: childhood malnutrition affects brain development, and 40% of children under five were stunted according to the National Nutrition Survey 2018. Improving maternal and child health, nutrition, parenting support and schooling would address both sides of the debate.
Conclusion
Hebb's rectangle analogy fits criminology well: asking whether nature or nurture causes crime is like asking whether length or width creates area. Both matter and work together. Biology may load the gun, but environment usually pulls the trigger. The practical lesson is to invest in healthy, nurturing environments for children, which is the most effective way to prevent crime.
Tags
- #Nature vs Nurture
- #Biosocial Criminology
- #Genetics and Crime
- #Twin Studies
- #Adoption Studies
- #MAOA Gene
- #Environment and Crime
- #Social Learning
- #Criminological Theory
- #CSS Criminology 2020
- #csssolvedpapers
- #csssolvedpapers2020
- #CSS Criminology Solved Paper 2020
- #What is your position on the nature vs
This topic in other CSS papers
Examiners return to the same themes. Compare how the question was framed in other years.
- CSS 2021 · Q. 2Critically analyze the biological theories of criminality.Common topic: Twin Studies, Biosocial Criminology
- CSS 2019 · Q. 3Discuss the fundamental postulates of Edwin Sutherland's 'Differential Association theory' with examples.Common topic: Social Learning
- CSS 2017 · Q. 3Enlist the criminological perspectives. Briefly describe the three criminological perspectives on the study of crime and criminal behaviour.Common topic: Social Learning
Browse every CSS Criminology solved past paper or the full library of CSS solved past papers, and compare with the original CSS 2020 Criminology question paper.
Answered this question differently?
Submit your own answer — approved answers are published with your name.
Get new solved papers on WhatsApp
Follow the CSS Nexus channel to hear first when new answers are published.

Corrections and discussion
Nothing here yet. Spotted a mistake in this answer, or have a suggestion? Tell us below.