CSS 2019CriminologyQ. 6
Define and differentiate interviewing and interrogation techniques. How far human rights of criminals are being violated during the interrogation process?
#cssnexusBy CSS Nexus Team ·
This answer to the CSS 2019 Criminology paper (Q. 6) was written by the CSS Nexus team. Read the outline first, then see how each point is developed.
Outline
- 1. Introduction
- 2. Definitions of interviewing and interrogation
- 3. Differences between interviewing and interrogation
- ✓Purpose; subject; tone; setting; questioning style; length; legal safeguards; outcome
- 4. How far human rights are violated during interrogation
- ✓Torture; custodial deaths; illegal detention; denial of counsel; forced confessions; abuse of vulnerable groups; enforced disappearances; impunity
- 5. Legal protections and reforms
- 6. Conclusion
Answer
Introduction
Article 14(2) of the Constitution of Pakistan declares: "No person shall be subjected to torture for the purpose of extracting evidence." Yet human rights organisations continue to report torture and custodial deaths in Pakistan. The way police question victims, witnesses and suspects is therefore both a matter of investigative skill and a test of the rule of law. Interviewing and interrogation are different tools with different purposes, and the line between lawful interrogation and abuse is often crossed.
Definitions of interviewing and interrogation
An interview is a planned, non-accusatory conversation to obtain information from a victim, witness or person who may know about a crime. An interrogation is the formal, accusatory questioning of a suspect who is reasonably believed to be involved in a crime, aimed at obtaining the truth, including admissions or a confession. Inbau and Reid describe interrogation as "an accusatory process" used only when the investigator is reasonably certain of the suspect's guilt, while modern ethical models such as the UK's PEACE prefer "investigative interviewing" for all subjects.
Differences between interviewing and interrogation
1. Purpose.
Interviews gather information; interrogations seek to test the suspect's account and obtain admissions. (Reference: Fred E. Inbau et al., Criminal Interrogation and Confessions, 5th ed., Jones & Bartlett, 2013.)
2. Subject.
Interviews involve victims, witnesses and sometimes suspects; interrogations involve suspects or accused persons. (Reference: Charles R. Swanson et al., Criminal Investigation, 12th ed., McGraw-Hill, 2019, ch. 6.)
3. Tone.
Interviews are friendly and non-accusatory; interrogations are accusatory and confrontational, though they must remain lawful. (Reference: Inbau et al., 2013.)
4. Setting.
Interviews can take place at the scene, home or office; interrogations take place in a controlled, private setting such as a police station. (Reference: Swanson et al., ch. 6.)
5. Questioning style.
Interviews use open-ended questions and free narrative; interrogations use more direct questions, presentation of evidence and challenge of inconsistencies. (Reference: Rebecca Milne and Ray Bull, Investigative Interviewing, Wiley, 1999.)
6. Length and structure.
Interviews are usually shorter and flexible; interrogations are planned, structured and may be longer. (Reference: Swanson et al., ch. 6.)
7. Legal safeguards.
A suspect under interrogation is entitled to safeguards such as being informed of the grounds of arrest, access to a lawyer and production before a magistrate within 24 hours. (Reference: Constitution of Pakistan, art. 10.)
8. Outcome.
Interviews produce witness statements under s. 161 CrPC; interrogations may lead to a confession, which is admissible only if recorded by a magistrate under s. 164 CrPC. (Reference: Code of Criminal Procedure 1898, ss. 161 and 164; Qanun-e-Shahadat Order 1984, art. 38.)
Interview vs interrogation
- Purpose
- Subject
- Tone
- Setting
- Questioning style
- Length
- Legal safeguards
- Outcome
How far human rights are violated during interrogation
1. Torture.
Beating, hanging upside down, sleep deprivation and other methods are widely reported in police custody. A Justice Project Pakistan study with Yale Law School documented extensive use of torture in Faisalabad district. (Reference: Justice Project Pakistan and Allard K. Lowenstein Human Rights Clinic, Yale Law School, Policing as Torture, 2014.)
2. Custodial deaths.
Deaths in custody occur regularly; the death of Salahuddin Ayubi in Rahim Yar Khan police custody in September 2019 caused national outrage. (Reference: Human Rights Commission of Pakistan, State of Human Rights in 2019.)
3. Illegal detention.
Suspects are often held without being produced before a magistrate within 24 hours, or kept in private torture cells, against Article 10. (Reference: Constitution of Pakistan, art. 10; HRCP annual reports.)
4. Denial of legal counsel.
Suspects are rarely given access to a lawyer during interrogation, leaving them without protection. (Reference: Constitution, art. 10(1); UN Basic Principles on the Role of Lawyers, 1990, principle 7.)
5. Forced confessions.
Confessions are extracted by torture or threats and then retracted in court, undermining both justice and conviction rates. (Reference: Qanun-e-Shahadat Order 1984, art. 37; Supreme Court of Pakistan judgments on retracted confessions.)
6. Abuse of vulnerable groups.
Women, children, the poor and minorities are especially vulnerable; female suspects are sometimes interrogated without female officers. (Reference: Juvenile Justice System Act 2018; CrPC s. 52 (search of women by women).)
7. Enforced disappearances.
People picked up by agencies without legal process are interrogated outside the legal system; the Commission of Inquiry on Enforced Disappearances has received thousands of cases since 2011. (Reference: Commission of Inquiry on Enforced Disappearances, monthly reports.)
8. Impunity.
Few officers are prosecuted for torture, and until 2022 Pakistan had no specific law criminalising it, despite ratifying the UN Convention against Torture in 2010. (Reference: UN Convention against Torture, ratified by Pakistan 2010; UN Committee against Torture, Concluding Observations on Pakistan, 2017.)
Rights violations
- 01Torture
- 02Custodial deaths
- 03Illegal detention
- 04No lawyer
- 05Forced confessions
- 06Vulnerable groups
- 07Disappearances
- 08Impunity
Legal protections and reforms
Pakistan enacted the Torture and Custodial Death (Prevention and Punishment) Act 2022, which defines torture, criminalises it and gives the FIA and the National Commission for Human Rights a role in investigating complaints. The Supreme Court and High Courts have repeatedly ordered action against illegal detention through habeas corpus under Article 199. Remaining reforms include audio-video recording of interrogations, independent medical examinations of detainees, CCTV in police stations, training in ethical methods such as PEACE, and accountability of officers.
Conclusion
As Article 14(2) of the Constitution insists, evidence must never be extracted by torture. Interviews and interrogations differ in purpose, tone and legal safeguards, but both must respect human dignity. Human rights violations during interrogation in Pakistan remain serious and widespread, harming innocent people and weakening justice. Enforcing the 2022 torture law and modernising interrogation methods would make investigations both more humane and more effective.
Tags
- #Interviewing
- #Interrogation
- #Human Rights
- #Torture
- #Custodial Death
- #Torture and Custodial Death Act 2022
- #Article 14
- #UN Convention against Torture
- #Pakistan Police
- #CSS Criminology 2019
- #csssolvedpapers
- #csssolvedpapers2019
- #CSS Criminology Solved Paper 2019
- #Define and differentiate interviewing and interrogation techniques. How
- #How far human rights of criminals are being
This topic in other CSS papers
Examiners return to the same themes. Compare how the question was framed in other years.
- CSS 2016 · Q. 7Discuss in detail the "Interviewing and Interrogation Techniques" of investigation.Common topic: Interviewing, Human Rights
- CSS 2021 · Q. 6What are the principles and techniques of interrogation? How far these techniques have potential to clear an accused?Common topic: Interrogation
- CSS Special 2023 · 2023Evaluate the efficacy of the investigation processes being practiced in Pakistan, adding suggestions for improvement therein.Common topic: Torture
- CSS 2022 · Q. 5In Pakistan, the creation of police force is a colonial legacy. In which circumstances independent police force was established in the pre-independence era. What major changes have been occurred in the police department in Pakistan?Common topic: Pakistan Police
- CSS 2018 · Q. 5Trace back the history and development of police organization in Pakistan.Common topic: Pakistan Police
Browse every CSS Criminology solved past paper or the full library of CSS solved past papers, and compare with the original CSS 2019 Criminology question paper.
Answered this question differently?
Submit your own answer — approved answers are published with your name.
Get new solved papers on WhatsApp
Follow the CSS Nexus channel to hear first when new answers are published.

Corrections and discussion
Nothing here yet. Spotted a mistake in this answer, or have a suggestion? Tell us below.