CSS 2021CriminologyQ. 6
What are the principles and techniques of interrogation? How far these techniques have potential to clear an accused?
#cssnexusBy CSS Nexus Team ·
This answer to the CSS 2021 Criminology paper (Q. 6) was written by the CSS Nexus team. Read the outline first, then see how each point is developed.
Outline
- 1. Introduction
- 2. Overview: interrogation and its purpose
- 3. Principles of interrogation
- ✓Legality; voluntariness; preparation; open mind; respect and rapport; privacy; recording; fairness to vulnerable suspects
- 4. Techniques of interrogation
- ✓PEACE; strategic use of evidence; cognitive techniques; Reid technique; rapport-based questioning; good cop-bad cop; polygraph and other aids; confrontation with inconsistencies
- 5. How far can these techniques clear an accused?
- ✓Verifiable alibis; exposing false accusations; consistency testing; link to physical evidence; information-gathering models; risks of accusatory methods; false confessions; safeguards
- 6. Conclusion
Answer
Introduction
Sir William Blackstone famously wrote that "it is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer." Interrogation is usually seen as a way to make the guilty confess, but properly conducted it is just as much a way to discover that a suspect is innocent. The principles and techniques used decide whether interrogation uncovers the truth or produces false confessions.
Overview
Interrogation is the structured questioning of a suspect to obtain accurate information about a crime, including any admission of guilt. In Pakistan, interrogation is regulated by the Constitution (Articles 10, 10A and 14), the CrPC 1898 and the Qanun-e-Shahadat Order 1984, under which a confession to the police is inadmissible (Article 38) and a confession becomes valid only when recorded by a magistrate under section 164 CrPC after ensuring it is voluntary.
Principles of interrogation
1. Legality.
Interrogation must follow the law: lawful custody, production before a magistrate within 24 hours, and no torture. (Reference: Constitution of Pakistan, arts. 10 and 14(2).)
2. Voluntariness.
Statements must be given freely; inducement, threat or promise makes a confession irrelevant. (Reference: Qanun-e-Shahadat Order 1984, art. 37.)
3. Thorough preparation.
The interrogator must know the evidence, scene and suspect's background before questioning. (Reference: Fred E. Inbau et al., Criminal Interrogation and Confessions, 5th ed., Jones & Bartlett, 2013.)
4. An open mind.
The aim is the truth, not a confession; the interrogator must be ready to accept innocence. (Reference: College of Policing (UK), Investigative Interviewing, APP; Police Rules 1934, r. 25.2.)
5. Respect and rapport.
Treating the suspect with dignity encourages cooperation and reliable information. (Reference: Rebecca Milne and Ray Bull, Investigative Interviewing, Wiley, 1999.)
6. Privacy and controlled setting.
Questioning should take place in a quiet, private room free from distractions and outside pressure. (Reference: Charles R. Swanson et al., Criminal Investigation, 12th ed., McGraw-Hill, 2019, ch. 6.)
7. Recording.
Accurate written, audio or video records protect the suspect and the interrogator and allow courts to assess voluntariness. (Reference: UK Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, Code E; CrPC 1898, s. 164.)
8. Fairness to vulnerable suspects.
Juveniles, women and mentally disabled persons need special safeguards, such as the presence of a guardian, lawyer or female officer. (Reference: Juvenile Justice System Act 2018; UN Principles on Effective Interviewing for Investigations and Information Gathering (Méndez Principles), 2021.)
Principles of interrogation
- Legality
- Voluntariness
- Preparation
- Open mind
- Respect
- Privacy
- Recording
- Vulnerable suspects
Techniques of interrogation
1. The PEACE model.
Planning, Engage and explain, Account, Closure, Evaluation: an information-gathering approach used in England since the 1990s. (Reference: College of Policing, Investigative Interviewing.)
2. Strategic use of evidence.
The suspect gives his full account first; evidence is then disclosed gradually to test it. (Reference: Pär Anders Granhag and Maria Hartwig, "The Strategic Use of Evidence Technique", in Detecting Deception, Wiley, 2015.)
3. Cognitive techniques.
Asking for events in reverse order or with full detail increases the mental load on liars and helps truthful suspects recall more. (Reference: Aldert Vrij et al., "Increasing Cognitive Load to Facilitate Lie Detection", Law and Human Behavior, vol. 32, 2008.)
4. The Reid technique.
A behavioural analysis interview followed by nine steps of direct confrontation, theme development and overcoming denials. (Reference: Inbau et al., 2013.)
5. Rapport-based questioning.
Building trust and showing empathy, used successfully even with terrorism suspects, often yields more information than pressure. (Reference: Laurence Alison et al., "Why Tough Tactics Fail and Rapport Gets Results", Psychology, Public Policy, and Law, vol. 19, 2013.)
6. Good cop-bad cop.
One officer is hostile and another sympathetic, encouraging the suspect to confide in the friendly one; it is criticised as manipulative. (Reference: Swanson et al., ch. 6.)
7. Polygraph and other aids.
The polygraph measures physiological responses; it can guide inquiries but is not reliable proof and is not admissible as evidence of guilt in most systems. (Reference: National Research Council, The Polygraph and Lie Detection, National Academies Press, 2003.)
8. Confrontation with inconsistencies.
Pointing out contradictions between the suspect's statements and the evidence can reveal lies or clarify misunderstandings. (Reference: Milne and Bull, 1999.)
Techniques
- 1
PEACE
- 2
Strategic use of evidence
- 3
Cognitive load
- 4
Reid technique
- 5
Rapport-based
- 6
Good cop-bad cop
- 7
Polygraph
- 8
Confronting inconsistencies
How far can these techniques clear an accused?
1. Verifying alibis.
Detailed, open questioning produces an account of the suspect's whereabouts that can be checked through witnesses, CCTV and phone records. (Reference: Swanson et al., ch. 6.)
2. Exposing false accusations.
Careful questioning can reveal that a complainant's story, motivated by enmity or land disputes, is false, a common problem in Pakistan's FIRs. (Reference: Police Rules 1934, r. 25.2; Pakistan Penal Code 1860, s. 182 (false information to a public servant).)
3. Consistency testing.
A truthful suspect's account usually remains consistent with evidence and over time. (Reference: Vrij, Detecting Lies and Deceit, 2nd ed., Wiley, 2008.)
4. Linking to physical evidence.
Information from interrogation can lead to evidence, such as DNA or documents, that excludes the suspect. (Reference: Innocence Project, DNA Exonerations.)
5. Information-gathering models protect the innocent.
PEACE and similar models aim at the truth rather than a confession, and research shows they reduce false confessions. (Reference: Saul M. Kassin et al., "Police-Induced Confessions: Risk Factors and Recommendations", Law and Human Behavior, vol. 34, 2010.)
6. Accusatory techniques can endanger the innocent.
Methods that presume guilt, such as aggressive confrontation, can pressure innocent people, especially the young or vulnerable, into confessing. (Reference: Kassin et al., 2010.)
7. False confessions are real.
More than a quarter of DNA exonerations in the USA involved false confessions, showing that interrogation can wrongly incriminate as well as clear. (Reference: Innocence Project, "False Confessions and Recording of Custodial Interrogations".)
8. Safeguards make clearing possible.
Recording interrogations, access to lawyers and judicial scrutiny of confessions under section 164 CrPC are what allow interrogation to clear the innocent rather than convict them. (Reference: CrPC 1898, s. 164; Méndez Principles, 2021.)
Can interrogation clear the accused?
- 01Alibis verified
- 02False accusations exposed
- 03Consistent accounts
- 04New evidence
- 05PEACE protects
- 06Accusatory risks
- 07False confessions
- 08Safeguards
Conclusion
Blackstone's principle that it is better for ten guilty to escape than for one innocent to suffer should guide every interrogation. Lawful, voluntary, well-prepared and recorded interrogation using information-gathering techniques has real potential to clear innocent suspects, by verifying alibis and exposing false accusations. Coercive, accusatory methods, still common in Pakistan, carry the opposite risk. The potential of interrogation to clear an accused depends entirely on the principles and safeguards under which it is carried out.
Tags
- #Interrogation
- #Principles of Interrogation
- #PEACE Model
- #Reid Technique
- #Cognitive Interview
- #False Confessions
- #Exoneration
- #Qanun-e-Shahadat
- #Pakistan
- #CSS Criminology 2021
- #csssolvedpapers
- #csssolvedpapers2021
- #CSS Criminology Solved Paper 2021
- #What are the principles and techniques of interrogation
- #How far these techniques have potential to clear
This topic in other CSS papers
Examiners return to the same themes. Compare how the question was framed in other years.
- CSS 2016 · Q. 7Discuss in detail the "Interviewing and Interrogation Techniques" of investigation.Common topic: PEACE Model, Reid Technique
- CSS 2018 · Q. 6What is Criminal investigation? Explain the key principles of criminal investigation.Common topic: Qanun-e-Shahadat
- CSS 2019 · Q. 6Define and differentiate interviewing and interrogation techniques. How far human rights of criminals are being violated during the interrogation process?Common topic: Interrogation
- CSS 2016 · Q. 6Enlist and discuss the principles of Criminal Investigation.Common topic: Qanun-e-Shahadat
Browse every CSS Criminology solved past paper or the full library of CSS solved past papers, and compare with the original CSS 2021 Criminology question paper.
Answered this question differently?
Submit your own answer — approved answers are published with your name.
Get new solved papers on WhatsApp
Follow the CSS Nexus channel to hear first when new answers are published.

Corrections and discussion
Nothing here yet. Spotted a mistake in this answer, or have a suggestion? Tell us below.