CSS 2025CriminologyQ. 7
Describe following types of legal Justice: (a) Retributive Justice (b) Procedural Justice (c) Distributive Justice (d) Restorative Justice
#cssnexusBy CSS Nexus Team ·
Original CSS 2025 Criminology paper Original CSS 2016–2026 Criminology paper
This answer to the CSS 2025 Criminology paper (Q. 7) was written by the CSS Nexus team. Read the outline first, then see how each point is developed.
Outline
- 1. Introduction
- 2. (a) Retributive justice
- 3. (b) Procedural justice
- 4. (c) Distributive justice
- 5. (d) Restorative justice
- 6. Comparison and relevance to Pakistan
- 7. Conclusion
Answer
Introduction
John Rawls opened A Theory of Justice (1971) with the words: "Justice is the first virtue of social institutions, as truth is of systems of thought." Justice, however, has many dimensions. It can mean giving offenders what they deserve, treating people fairly in procedures, sharing society's benefits and burdens fairly, or repairing the harm caused by crime. These correspond to retributive, procedural, distributive and restorative justice.
(a) Retributive justice
(a) Retributive justice
- Meaning
- Philosophical roots
- Proportionality
- Backward-looking
- Moral condemnation
- Islamic parallel
- Application in Pakistan
- Criticism
1. Meaning.
Retributive justice holds that offenders should be punished because they deserve it, in proportion to the seriousness of their crime. (Reference: Andrew von Hirsch, Doing Justice: The Choice of Punishments, Hill and Wang, 1976.)
2. Philosophical roots. Immanuel Kant argued that punishment must be imposed because a crime was committed, not merely for its useful effects. (Reference: Immanuel Kant, The Metaphysics of Morals, 1797.)
3. Proportionality.
The punishment should fit the crime: "just deserts." (Reference: von Hirsch, 1976.)
4. Backward-looking.
It focuses on the past offence rather than future consequences. (Reference: Andrew Ashworth, Sentencing and Criminal Justice, 6th ed., Cambridge University Press, 2015.)
5. Moral condemnation.
Punishment expresses society's condemnation of wrongdoing. (Reference: Joel Feinberg, "The Expressive Function of Punishment", The Monist, vol. 49, 1965.)
6. Islamic parallel.
The principle of qisas (equal retribution) in the Quran, "there is for you in legal retribution [saving of] life" (Al-Baqarah 2:179), reflects proportional retribution, tempered by forgiveness and diyat. (Reference: Quran 2:178-179.)
7. Application in Pakistan.
The PPC prescribes punishments graded by seriousness, including death for murder and terrorism. (Reference: Pakistan Penal Code 1860, ss. 53 and 302.)
8. Criticism.
It may ignore causes of crime and the needs of victims and offenders, and harsh punishment does not always reduce crime. (Reference: Ashworth, 2015.)
(b) Procedural justice
(b) Procedural justice
- Meaning
- Voice
- Neutrality
- Respect and dignity
- Trustworthy motives
- Legal basis in Pakistan
- Legitimacy and compliance
- Criticism
1. Meaning.
Procedural justice concerns the fairness of the processes by which decisions are made, regardless of the outcome. (Reference: Tom R. Tyler, Why People Obey the Law, Princeton University Press, 2006.)
2. Voice.
People should have the chance to tell their side before decisions are made. (Reference: John Thibaut and Laurens Walker, Procedural Justice: A Psychological Analysis, Erlbaum, 1975.)
3. Neutrality.
Decision-makers must be impartial and base decisions on facts and law. (Reference: Tyler, 2006.)
4. Respect and dignity.
People must be treated politely and with respect for their rights. (Reference: Tyler, 2006.)
5. Trustworthy motives.
Authorities should show they are acting in good faith and care about the people affected. (Reference: Tyler, 2006.)
6. Legal basis in Pakistan. Article 10A of the Constitution guarantees the right to a fair trial and due process. (Reference: Constitution of Pakistan, art. 10A, inserted by the 18th Amendment, 2010.)
7. Legitimacy and compliance.
Research shows people obey the law and cooperate with police more when they see procedures as fair. (Reference: Tyler, 2006.)
8. Criticism.
Fair procedures can still produce unjust outcomes if laws themselves are unjust or institutions are biased. (Reference: Rawls, A Theory of Justice, 1971, on pure and imperfect procedural justice.)
(c) Distributive justice
(c) Distributive justice
- 1
Meaning
- 2
Aristotle's view
- 3
Rawls's principles
- 4
Libertarian view
- 5
Link with crime
- 6
Islamic perspective
- 7
Application in Pakistan
- 8
Criticism
1. Meaning.
Distributive justice concerns the fair allocation of resources, opportunities, rights and burdens in society. (Reference: John Rawls, A Theory of Justice, Harvard University Press, 1971.)
2. Aristotle's view.
Aristotle described distributive justice as distribution according to merit or proportion. (Reference: Aristotle, Nicomachean Ethics, Book V.)
3. Rawls's principles.
Rawls argued for equal basic liberties and that inequalities are justified only if they benefit the least advantaged (the difference principle). (Reference: Rawls, 1971.)
4. Libertarian view. Robert Nozick argued that a distribution is just if it arises from fair acquisition and transfer, opposing redistribution. (Reference: Robert Nozick, Anarchy, State, and Utopia, Basic Books, 1974.)
5. Link with crime.
Unequal distribution of wealth and opportunity fuels strain and crime, as Merton and conflict theorists argue. (Reference: Robert K. Merton, "Social Structure and Anomie", 1938.)
6. Islamic perspective.
Zakat, inheritance law and prohibition of hoarding promote fair distribution, so that wealth is not "a perpetual distribution among the rich from among you" (Al-Hashr 59:7). (Reference: Quran 59:7; 9:60.)
7. Application in Pakistan.
Article 38 of the Constitution commits the state to the well-being of the people and to reducing disparities of income; programmes such as BISP reflect this. (Reference: Constitution of Pakistan, art. 38.)
8. Criticism.
Disagreement over what counts as fair, merit, need or equality, makes distributive justice contested. (Reference: Michael Sandel, Justice: What's the Right Thing to Do?, Farrar, Straus and Giroux, 2009.)
(d) Restorative justice
1. Meaning.
Restorative justice focuses on repairing the harm caused by crime through the involvement of victims, offenders and the community. (Reference: Howard Zehr, Changing Lenses: A New Focus for Crime and Justice, Herald Press, 1990.)
2. Crime as harm.
It views crime as a violation of people and relationships, not just of the state's law. (Reference: Zehr, 1990.)
3. Victim participation.
Victims have a voice, receive answers and can obtain restitution. (Reference: UN Basic Principles on the Use of Restorative Justice Programmes in Criminal Matters, ECOSOC Res. 2002/12.)
4. Offender accountability.
Offenders take responsibility and make amends rather than passively receiving punishment. (Reference: John Braithwaite, Crime, Shame and Reintegration, Cambridge University Press, 1989.)
5. Methods.
Victim-offender mediation, family group conferencing (as in New Zealand's youth justice since 1989) and peace circles. (Reference: New Zealand Children, Young Persons, and Their Families Act 1989.)
6. Reintegration.
It aims to restore relationships and reintegrate offenders into the community. (Reference: UNODC, Handbook on Restorative Justice Programmes, 2nd ed., 2020.)
7. Application in Pakistan.
Diversion and compensation under the Juvenile Justice System Act 2018, compounding of offences under section 345 CrPC, and traditional suleh reflect restorative ideas. (Reference: Juvenile Justice System Act 2018; CrPC 1898, s. 345.)
8. Criticism.
It may pressure victims to forgive, be unsuitable for serious violence, and be abused where powerful families force compromises, as in honour killing cases before 2016. (Reference: HRCP reports; Criminal Law (Amendment) Act 2016.)
Four types of justice
- 01Retributive: deserved punishment
- 02Procedural: fair process
- 03Distributive: fair sharing
- 04Restorative: repairing harm
Comparison and relevance to Pakistan
Retributive justice asks what the offender deserves; procedural justice asks whether the process was fair; distributive justice asks whether society's resources are fairly shared; restorative justice asks how the harm can be repaired. A balanced criminal justice system in Pakistan needs all four: proportionate punishment, fair trials under Article 10A, reduction of the inequalities that breed crime, and restorative options for juveniles and minor offences, without allowing compromise to shield powerful offenders.
Conclusion
Rawls called justice "the first virtue of social institutions." Retributive, procedural, distributive and restorative justice are different faces of that virtue. Together they ensure that offenders are punished fairly, people are treated fairly, society is organised fairly and harm is repaired, which is the true aim of any legal system.
Tags
- #Retributive Justice
- #Procedural Justice
- #Distributive Justice
- #Restorative Justice
- #Theories of Punishment
- #John Rawls
- #Tom Tyler
- #Qisas
- #Pakistan
- #CSS Criminology 2025
- #csssolvedpapers
- #csssolvedpapers2025
- #CSS Criminology Solved Paper 2025
- #Describe following types of legal Justice: (a) Retributive
This topic in other CSS papers
Examiners return to the same themes. Compare how the question was framed in other years.
- CSS 2026 · Q. 6Discuss how declining public trust in institutions can contribute to deviant behaviour, non-cooperation, and social resistance in Pakistani society.Common topic: Procedural Justice
- CSS 2020 · Q. 8Explain the institutional corrections and alternative community corrections strategies in detail. Support your answer with examples where appropriate.Common topic: Restorative Justice
- CSS 2019 · Q. 5How far recidivism has been limited by the institution of prison? Explain some of the modern strategies used in prison for the restoration and reintegration of criminals.Common topic: Restorative Justice
Browse every CSS Criminology solved past paper or the full library of CSS solved past papers, and compare with the original CSS 2025 Criminology question paper.
Answered this question differently?
Submit your own answer — approved answers are published with your name.
Get new solved papers on WhatsApp
Follow the CSS Nexus channel to hear first when new answers are published.

Corrections and discussion
Nothing here yet. Spotted a mistake in this answer, or have a suggestion? Tell us below.