CSS NEXUS
CSS Solved Criminology

CSS 2026CriminologyQ. 6

Discuss how declining public trust in institutions can contribute to deviant behaviour, non-cooperation, and social resistance in Pakistani society.

By CSS Nexus Team ·

Original CSS 2026 Criminology paper Original CSS 2016–2026 Criminology paper

This answer to the CSS 2026 Criminology paper (Q. 6) was written by the CSS Nexus team. Read the outline first, then see how each point is developed.

Outline

  • 1. Introduction
  • 2. Overview: trust, legitimacy and compliance
  • 3. Causes of declining trust in Pakistan's institutions
  • ✓Corruption; delayed justice; police abuse; political instability; selective accountability; poor service delivery; elite privilege; misinformation
  • 4. How declining trust contributes to deviance, non-cooperation and resistance
  • ✓Weakening belief in rules; tax evasion and informality; non-reporting of crime; vigilantism and mob justice; informal justice systems; protests and civil disobedience; radicalisation; brain drain and disengagement
  • 5. Rebuilding trust
  • 6. Conclusion

Answer

Introduction

Confucius is reported to have taught that a ruler needs weapons, food and the trust of the people, and that if one must give up something, trust should be kept last, because "without trust we cannot stand." Modern criminology agrees. Tom Tyler's research shows that people obey the law mainly because they see authorities as legitimate, not only because they fear punishment. When trust in the police, courts, parliament and bureaucracy declines, compliance weakens and deviance, non-cooperation and resistance grow, a pattern visible in Pakistan.

Overview

Trust in institutions is the belief that they are fair, competent and act in the public interest. Legitimacy is the resulting sense that authorities have the right to be obeyed. Surveys in Pakistan regularly show low confidence in the police, political parties and parts of the judiciary, while the armed forces and some religious institutions score higher. Durkheim's idea of anomie and Hirschi's element of belief in social bond theory both suggest that when people lose faith in the system's rules, they feel freer to break them.

The trust cycle

  1. Unfair or failing institutions
  2. Loss of trust
  3. Loss of legitimacy
  4. Less compliance
  5. More deviance and resistance
  6. Weaker institutions

Causes of declining trust in Pakistan's institutions

1. Corruption.

Widespread bribery in police, revenue and other departments erodes faith in fairness. (Reference: Transparency International Pakistan, National Corruption Perception Survey 2023.)

2. Delayed justice.

Over two million cases pending in courts mean justice is slow and uncertain. (Reference: Law and Justice Commission of Pakistan, Judicial Statistics of Pakistan 2023.)

3. Police abuse.

Torture, fake encounters and illegal detention damage trust in law enforcement. (Reference: HRCP, State of Human Rights reports; Justice Project Pakistan, Policing as Torture, 2014.)

4. Political instability.

Frequent government changes, disputed elections and confrontation between institutions undermine confidence in democracy. (Reference: PILDAT, Assessment of the Quality of Democracy in Pakistan.)

5. Selective accountability.

Perceptions that accountability targets opponents while sparing allies weaken trust in anti-corruption bodies. (Reference: International Crisis Group, Pakistan reports.)

6. Poor service delivery.

Inadequate schools, hospitals, water and electricity make citizens feel the state does not serve them. (Reference: UNDP, Pakistan National Human Development Report 2020.)

7. Elite privilege.

Visible privileges and tax exemptions for elites create a sense that rules apply only to the weak. (Reference: UNDP, NHDR 2020, estimate of elite privilege at US$17.4 billion a year.)

8. Misinformation.

Social media rumours and propaganda spread distrust, sometimes faster than facts. (Reference: Digital Rights Foundation reports on disinformation in Pakistan.)

Causes of distrust

  • Corruption
  • Delayed justice
  • Police abuse
  • Political instability
  • Selective accountability
  • Poor services
  • Elite privilege
  • Misinformation

How declining trust contributes to deviance, non-cooperation and resistance

1. Weakening belief in rules.

When institutions are seen as unfair, people stop seeing laws as morally binding and justify breaking them. (Reference: Tom R. Tyler, Why People Obey the Law, Princeton University Press, 2006.)

2. Tax evasion and informality.

Distrust in how revenue is used encourages tax evasion and a large informal economy; Pakistan's tax-to-GDP ratio has long been around 10%, among the lowest in the region. (Reference: World Bank, Pakistan Development Update; Federal Board of Revenue data.)

3. Non-reporting of crime and refusal to testify.

Citizens avoid the police and courts, so crimes go unreported and offenders escape. (Reference: Wesley G. Skogan, Police and Community in Chicago, 2006.)

4. Vigilantism and mob justice.

When people believe the state will not deliver justice, they take the law into their own hands, as in mob lynchings such as the killing of Mashal Khan (2017) and the Sialkot lynching of Priyantha Kumara (2021). (Reference: HRCP, State of Human Rights in 2017 and 2021.)

5. Informal justice systems.

Distrust drives people to jirgas and panchayats, which may issue unlawful decisions such as swara or honour punishments. (Reference: Supreme Court of Pakistan rulings against jirgas; HRCP reports.)

6. Protests and civil disobedience.

Loss of faith leads to blockades, sit-ins and calls for non-payment of bills, sometimes turning violent, as during the 9 May 2023 riots. (Reference: Pakistan Institute for Peace Studies; HRCP, State of Human Rights in 2023.)

7. Radicalisation.

Militant groups exploit distrust, presenting themselves as alternatives to a corrupt or unjust state. (Reference: NACTA, National Internal Security Policy 2018-23.)

8. Brain drain and disengagement.

Many educated young people lose hope and emigrate or withdraw from civic life, weakening social capital. (Reference: Bureau of Emigration and Overseas Employment, annual data; Robert D. Putnam, Bowling Alone, Simon and Schuster, 2000.)

Effects of distrust

  • 01Rules lose force
  • 02Tax evasion
  • 03Non-reporting
  • 04Mob justice
  • 05Informal justice
  • 06Protests
  • 07Radicalisation
  • 08Disengagement

Rebuilding trust

Pakistan can rebuild trust through procedural justice in policing and courts, faster trials, transparent and impartial accountability, an end to elite privileges, better public services, digital transparency in government transactions, protection of free media against misinformation, and genuine citizen participation through local government and community policing.

Conclusion

Confucius's warning that "without trust we cannot stand" applies directly to Pakistan. Declining trust in institutions, caused by corruption, delays, abuse and elite privilege, weakens the moral force of law and produces tax evasion, non-cooperation, vigilantism, informal justice and resistance. Restoring legitimacy through fairness and accountability is therefore not only a political necessity but a crucial crime-prevention strategy.

Tags

This topic in other CSS papers

Examiners return to the same themes. Compare how the question was framed in other years.

Browse every CSS Criminology solved past paper or the full library of CSS solved past papers, and compare with the original CSS 2026 Criminology question paper.

Corrections and discussion

Nothing here yet. Spotted a mistake in this answer, or have a suggestion? Tell us below.

Add your comment, correction or suggestion

Everything is checked by our team before it appears. Please keep it respectful and on topic.

Your rating (optional)

Answered this question differently?

Submit your own answer — approved answers are published with your name.

Submit your answer

Get new solved papers on WhatsApp

Follow the CSS Nexus channel to hear first when new answers are published.

Follow our WhatsApp channel

More solved Criminology